A good portrait is not always a good painting

Why capturing a face and painting a painting are not the same job
November 16, 2026
A good portrait is not always a good painting blog overlay on detail of purple portrait with blue flower in hair

A good portrait is not always a good painting

At Heatherley's I was taught by the wonderful artist Melissa Scott-Miller. She was the first to explain to me the difference between a good portrait and a good painting. I am paraphrasing here.

 

A good portrait and a good painting are not always the same thing. Sometimes the likeness is there in a bad painting, sometimes a great painting is a terrible portrait.

I am a painter who sometimes paints people. Sometimes, the paintings are portraits.

 

What if it looks like me? What if it doesn't?

 

There are two fears people have when sitting for a portrait:

  1. That the portrait will look nothing like them

  2. That the portrait will look exactly like them

 

As the artist, I have a fear of my own, that it is impossible to create a likeness of another human. That the moments I observe are too far removed from the self-perception of the person being observed.

 

Adding a photoshoot to my process was freeing because it solved part of this dilemma. Each model received a photographic portrait (by Anastasia Jobson) that looked beautiful and looked like them. That took the pressure off me to create a likeness.

Postcard Study: Ink Study S , 2026 · ink on watercolour postcard · 6 × 4″ Charlie Kirkham

Postcard Study:  ink on watercolour postcard · 6 × 4″

Instead I play with light and colour. I explore how little information a face needs to read as a human face. When the model receives their photograph, that frees me to really focus on the story behind the physicality.

 

Each model gives me a playlist to paint to. For this one it was the Henry Fraser musical The Little Big Things.

 

A study in light

Drawing and making a mini colour study helped me decide what each piece should focus on. With nearly 200 images per model I need a filter!

 

Heart Transplant, Hydrangea (Study), 2026 · oil on wood panel · 30 × 40 × 3 cm (unframed) Charlie Kirkham

Heart Transplant, Hydrangea (Study), 2026 · oil on wood panel · 30 × 40 × 3 cm (unframed) detail 

 

In this study (Heart Transplant, Hydrangea), the light and colour are the focus. The painting is an abstraction of the ink postcard. The model is unrecognisable. Here, I fell in love with the extreme light on the face. It was so bright it obscured the features but left the sense of serenity in her expression.

 

Cobalt violet

Cobalt violet is an essential colour in my palette. It is a colour beloved by portrait painters and I first encountered it via Fred Crayk at Heatherley's. It helps with facial shading on a wide range of skin tones. It is dazzling on its own! It is also a chameleon colour. Pair it with cobalt blue and it sings, add just a hint of lemon yellow and what magic is revealed.

 

What makes a good portrait?

This is where things become ambiguous. We cannot look at ourselves in the mirror, in photographs or in paintings without also seeing years of complex thoughts, feelings and self-image projected on top. What we see reflects our inner view more than any physical reality.

 

We are all of us impacted by the unattainable beauty standards that surround us, the ubiquity of visual images. Nowadays the even more impossible portraits AI generates make the ever-mutating aesthetic ideal eternally unreachable.*

 

When I think of the most successful portraits in art history, they all speak to something more in the sitter that transcends the physical. They tell us little secrets. They're also really great paintings.

 

Take Vuillard's The Artist's Mother Playing Checkers. It captures essence without an obvious likeness. To a stranger the woman is impossible to recognise and to someone who knows that particular tilt of the head, she is impossible to mistake. That to me is the contradictory nature of portraiture.

 

The past year of painting has given me greater trust in the ability of my painting to carry collections of moments. I trust that the person inside the painting can be found by those who need to see them. The paintings are stronger, quieter works.

 

Right now I'm working toward a solo show celebrating the power of the body and spirit to overcome darkness. Follow the journey and get first sight of new work. Join the mailing list.

 

 

*As an aside I love the work of Gretchen Andrew who explores Facetune's impact on portraiture and beauty.

 

About the author

Charlie Kirkham

UK Visual Artist based in the Midlands. 

Add a comment